Last updated: April 202612 min read

Shopify Checkout Best Practices

The average checkout abandonment rate is 70%. Here's how to optimize your Shopify checkout to recover lost sales.

By Samuel Noriega

Shopify Select Partner & Founder of Shugert Marketing

Key Takeaways

  • •Shop Pay increases checkout conversions by up to 50% compared to standard checkout
  • •Unexpected shipping costs are the #1 reason for checkout abandonment
  • •Guest checkout option is essential–forcing account creation loses sales
  • •Shopify Plus merchants can customize checkout with Checkout UI Extensions

Why Customers Abandon Checkout

Understanding why customers leave checkout is the first step to optimization. Here are the top reasons:

Top Checkout Abandonment Reasons

  • 48% - Extra costs too high (shipping, taxes, fees)
  • 26% - Required to create an account
  • 22% - Delivery was too slow
  • 18% - Didn't trust the site with credit card info
  • 17% - Checkout process was too complicated
  • 12% - Website had errors or crashed

If you can check 2 or more of these, you're leaving revenue on the table.

  • ☐Cart-to-checkout abandonment above 70%
  • ☐No express checkout (Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay) enabled
  • ☐Required account creation before purchase
  • ☐No abandoned-cart recovery email flow

We scope a fixed-price CRO Fix that addresses each leak, then sets up measurement so you can verify what moved.

Typical investment: $3,000–$5,000 · Turnaround: 2–4 weeks

See the CRO Fix

Shipping and Cost Transparency

Surprise costs are the number one conversion killer. Be transparent about all costs as early as possible.

Best Practices

  • Show shipping costs early: Display on product pages or cart before checkout
  • Free shipping threshold: Display progress toward free shipping clearly
  • Shipping calculator: Let customers estimate costs before checkout
  • All-inclusive pricing: Consider baking shipping into product prices

💡 Pro Tip

If you offer free shipping, mention it everywhere: product pages, cart, header banner. "Free shipping on orders over $50" is one of the most effective conversion boosters.

Guest Checkout and Account Creation

Forcing account creation is a major friction point. Always offer guest checkout.

Account Strategy

  • Guest checkout default: Make it the primary option
  • Post-purchase account creation: Offer to save info after purchase
  • Social login: Enable Google/Facebook/Apple sign-in
  • Shop Pay: Accelerated checkout that remembers customers

Shop Pay Advantages

Shop Pay stores customer information securely, enabling one-tap checkout for returning customers. Benefits include:

  • Up to 50% higher conversion rate
  • 4x faster checkout completion
  • Cross-store recognition (100M+ Shop Pay users)
  • Integrated order tracking via Shop app

Trust Signals in Checkout

Trust is critical at the moment of payment. Shopify's checkout is already optimized for trust, but you can enhance it further.

Standard Shopify Trust Features

  • SSL encryption (padlock icon)
  • PCI compliance messaging
  • Recognizable payment method logos
  • Shopify's trusted checkout design

Additional Trust Enhancements (Shopify Plus)

  • Money-back guarantee messaging
  • Customer service contact information
  • Trust badges (Norton, McAfee, etc.)
  • Company logos or branding

Payment Options

Offering multiple payment methods reduces friction for customers with different preferences.

Recommended Payment Options

  • Shop Pay: Shopify's accelerated checkout (essential)
  • PayPal: Still preferred by many customers
  • Apple Pay / Google Pay: Mobile-optimized checkout
  • Buy Now, Pay Later: Shop Pay Installments, Klarna, Afterpay
  • Credit/Debit cards: All major cards via Shopify Payments

Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)

BNPL options like Shop Pay Installments can increase average order value by 50% and conversion rates by 20%.

Mobile Checkout Optimization

Mobile checkout has higher abandonment rates than desktop. Optimize for thumb-friendly, fast experiences.

Mobile Checkout Best Practices

  • Enable Shop Pay and mobile wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)
  • Use numeric keyboard for phone and card number fields
  • Auto-format inputs (phone numbers, card numbers)
  • Large, thumb-friendly buttons
  • Minimize required fields
  • Address autocomplete

Shopify Plus Checkout Customization

Shopify Plus merchants have additional checkout customization options through Checkout UI Extensions.

Available Customizations

  • Branding: Custom colors, fonts, and logo
  • Content blocks: Add trust badges, upsells, gift messages
  • Custom fields: Delivery instructions, gift wrap options
  • Scripts: Automatic discounts, shipping logic, payment customization
  • Functions: Custom discount logic, shipping rates, payment methods

⚠️ Important

Checkout.liquid is deprecated. All new checkout customizations should use Checkout UI Extensions and Shopify Functions.

Cart Abandonment Recovery

Even with a perfect checkout, some customers will abandon. Recovery tactics can recapture 5-15% of lost sales.

Recovery Strategies

  • Email sequence: Send 2-3 emails within 24-72 hours
  • SMS reminders: Higher open rates than email
  • Exit-intent offers: Discount popup before leaving
  • Retargeting ads: Facebook/Instagram dynamic product ads
  • Persistent cart: Save cart for returning visitors

Abandonment Email Sequence

  • Email 1 (1 hour): "Did you forget something?" - Simple reminder
  • Email 2 (24 hours): Address objections, add reviews/trust
  • Email 3 (48-72 hours): Create urgency or offer discount

Fix the leak, not the symptoms.

We scope a fixed-price CRO Fix engagement: friction audit, product/checkout/cart redesign, post-purchase capture, and A/B test setup so you can measure the lift.

Typical investment: $3,000–$5,000 · Turnaround: 2–4 weeks

See the CRO Fix

Most quotes returned within 1 business day

Frequently Asked Questions

How much can checkout optimization actually lift conversion?
On Shopify stores we've worked with, focused checkout optimization typically lifts checkout completion rates by double-digit percentages – driven mostly by enabling Shop Pay, removing unnecessary form fields, and offering express payment methods above the fold.
Should I use Shopify's one-page checkout?
Yes for most merchants. Shopify's one-page checkout reduces friction by collapsing contact, shipping, and payment into a single scrollable view, and it's now the default on Shopify and Shopify Plus stores.
Is Shop Pay worth enabling?
Yes. Shop Pay typically converts well above guest checkout because it autofills shipping and payment for any returning Shop Pay user across the Shopify network – meaning even first-time customers to your store may already be one tap from purchase.
What checkout customizations are allowed on standard Shopify?
Standard Shopify allows a defined set of checkout extensions and Shopify Functions for customizing shipping, payment, and discount logic. Deep checkout.liquid customization is restricted to Shopify Plus stores that haven't migrated to checkout extensibility.
How do I reduce checkout abandonment?
Focus on three things: enable wallet payments (Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay) at the top of checkout, remove unnecessary form fields, and add trust signals like guarantees, security badges, and clear returns information directly on the checkout page.

CRO

Related Articles

Explore Shopify CRO agency

Product pages, checkout, customer journeys, instrumentation and conversion research.

CRO

Shopify CRO Playbook

A structured method for finding friction, prioritizing hypotheses and measuring changes.

Read article
CRO

Product Page Optimization

Product-page hierarchy, merchandising, trust and buying-friction improvements.

Read article
Shopify Engineering

Shopify Development Cost Guide

Realistic cost drivers for theme builds, apps, integrations, migrations and advanced Shopify work.

Read article